जै · The Jain Encyclopedia
Sūtra 5.29 · origination, cessation, persistence

What it means to exist

उत्पाद-व्यय-ध्रौव्य

Under all six substances, one definition: a thing exists if it originates, ceases and persists - all three at once. The pot is made and the lump of clay is gone and the clay remains.

Utpāda-vyaya-dhrauvya-yuktaṃ sat. Nothing that is real is only permanent or only changing; every substance keeps its nature while its states arise and pass. Gold stays gold while the bangle becomes the coin; the soul stays the soul while it is a god and then an ant; space stays space while what is in it moves. This is the sentence the whole doctrine of many-sidedness, anekānta, is built to protect, and the reason the six can be eternal and the universe can still have a history.

It is also why the six cannot be reduced to fewer. Each keeps a nature none of the others has - knowing, form, carrying motion, carrying rest, giving room, marking change - and each keeps it through every state. The count is six because that is how many natures there are.

The six, compared as the sūtra compares themTattvārthasūtra 5.1–22: what each is, and what each does for the restthree of the six are one substance apiece and do nothing but make the others possiblejīvasoulanantaasaṃkhyāta eachnoyesyesthe lokaDOESsouls help oneanother - 5.21the lamp, whichfills the room it isinpudgalamatteranantaone to anantayesyesyesthe lokaDOESbody, speech, mind,breath; pleasure,pain, life, death -5.19–20the clay, whichtakes every shapedharmathe medium of motion1asaṃkhyātanoyesnothe whole loka,exactlyDOESmotion - 5.17the water, whichlets the fish moveand pushes nothingadharmathe medium of rest1asaṃkhyātanoyesnothe whole loka,exactlyDOESrest - 5.17the shade, underwhich the travellerstops of his ownwillākāśaspace1anantanoyesnothe loka and beyondit, without endDOESroom - 5.18the vessel, whichholds and is notchanged by what itholdskālatimeby traditionnone - not a kāyanononothe human world, asreckoned;everywhere, asDOESbecoming, change,before and after -5.22the potter's wheel,on which the potturns and is notmadeHOW MANYSPACE-POINTSWITH FORMWITH EXTENSIONMOVESWHEREDOESLIKENESSthe five astikāyas - the substances with extensionWHAT IT MEANS TO EXIST - 5.29utpāda · vyaya · dhrauvya
The six, compared as the sūtra compares them - What it means to exist highlighted

Measurements and counts

Sūtra5.29
The threeutpāda · vyaya · dhrauvya
Togetheralways - none without the others
The likenessthe clay, the lump, the pot

Connected

Open in the interactive atlas →

समयं गोयम! मा पमायए

Do not be heedless, Gautama, for even a single samaya.

Uttarādhyayana Sūtra 10